The panel for the second show of the new series were Ted Ray, Clifford Davis, Mickie Most and John Smith.
The seven new acts who were looking to book a place in the first All Winners show were;
- Together (five-piece group) from Brighton
- Lennie Leighton (comedy / vocalist)
- Mint (group) from Leicester
- Dave Cartwright (folk singer)
- Johnnie Kennedy (comedian)
- Lynn and Alan (vocal instrumental duo)
The controversial winners of the show were Mint. The group formed back in 1967 and had previously appeared three times on Opportunity Knocks which would appear to bend the rules of appearing on New Faces.
The members of the group were Alan Jones (lead guitar), Martin Wright (lead vocals), Leigh Catterall (bass), George Moorley (drums) and Dennis Stansall (vocals and percussion). They scored 111 points with their own version of The Turtles song You Don’t Have To Walk In The Rain, securing the win and a place in the first All Winners Show of the series. They scored 37 for Presentation, Content and Star Quality with Ted Ray awarding them a maximum score of 10 in each category.
Ted Ray thought they produced a ‘wonderful sound’ and declared that they were ‘marvellous.’ Clifford Davis confessed he thought that show director Paul Stewart Laing was ‘a bit potty’ as he’d opened the show with the Brighton group Together, but when Mint performed he realised that the director had another great act up his sleeve and added ‘I think they are just as good as the first lot.’
The only thing Mickie Most didn’t like was what the band were dressed in, but added he thought this was their time to make it having served their ‘apprenticeship.’ John Smith stated that the group could work in concert venues, but unlike Together, they would also work well in clubs and cabaret too, calling them ‘a great act.’
The first act on the show, Brighton group Together, were awarded 103 points by the judges as shown in the clip below. They scored 33 for Presentation and an impressive 35 for both Content and Star Quality which including a maximum score of 10 from Clifford Davis (Content) and Mickie Most (Star Quality).
The group played under the names of Batman, Tarzan, Superman, Robin Hood and Popeye, however, their real names were Terry, Ray, Paul, Mick and Nigel.
The recording of the group Together performing their own song Mighty Murgatroyd on this show has been found and can be watched in the You Tube clip below.
The show viewers voted for comedian Johnnie Kennedy who would also appear, alongside Mint, on the first All Winners Show on the 9 November 1974.
Lynn and Alan White appeared on the scoreboard as just Lynn and Alan.